Recently I came across a Twitter thread that was quite interesting discussing the dangers of minimalist design and the death of detail. Being a big fan of minimalist design I was naturally pessimistic about this thread but as I read more I realised that it had some really good arguments so I thought I’d share them with you in this week’s blog.
Most people think a minimal design is a style that just strips everything away. Or does it just require lots of white space? Or just a white canvas with black type? Any of these things can be true. Or none of them can be true.
Minimalist graphic design is a philosophy of creating something where every element serves a purpose. It is simple, clean and beautiful. It is highly usable. These designs are easy for users to understand and engage with. It’s a philosophy I’ve tried to implement in my design work after hearing a quote from French poet Antoine de Saint-Exupery that really resonated with me:
“Perfection is achieved, not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is
nothing left to take away.”
However, as with most things it has a time and a place and over-use of minimal design can strip things of their uniqueness and originality. That’s what the twitter thread tries to explain starting with the architectural choices we see on a daily basis. Minimalism is a troubling phenomenon because of what it represents: a lack of detail.
Why does detail matter? Think of it as identity. The colour, the mouldings around a door and ornamentation at the top give the phone box detail and character something the phone box on the right lacks. This is relevant to Hull also as our white phone boxes are a unique representation of the city and have a part in our history. Something that would simply be lost if we scrapped them and replaced them with minimal corporate boxes.
The thread states that it isn't criticising someone for choosing minimal design - for example if they chose to design their house in a minimal, neutral way that’s their choice - however the social drift to absolute simplification is concerning with the worst crime being how minimal design strips colour away from almost anything. For example the pictures below show how monotone interiors are developing. Both demonstrate the monotone discipling but the more modern representation on the right lacks and real personality of definition.
Suddenly, everything, everywhere starts to look the same.
Absolute neutrality.
No detail. No identity.
What does that say about us? Ironically, perhaps it says a lot!